
How to increase average order value: 12 tactics, ranked
Twelve ways to get more revenue from each order, ranked by effort and likely payoff, with examples from Bombas, Brooklinen, Glossier and Allbirds.
Average order value · 6 min read
Post-purchase upsells are offers shown after a shopper pays, usually on a page before the thank-you screen. The shopper adds the item with one click, without typing card details again. Offer one cheap, related add-on at a small discount. Because the first order is already complete, the offer can't cost you that sale.
By The Growth Desk · Updated · 4 min read

Effort and impact are our estimates
| # | Tactic | Effort | Likely impact | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | One-click post-purchase page | Effort: Medium | Likely impact: High | Consumables, add-ons |
| 2 | Thank-you page offer | Effort: Low | Likely impact: Medium | Cross-sells, referrals |
| 3 | Order status page offer | Effort: Low | Likely impact: Low | Stores with long shipping times |
| 4 | Follow-up cross-sell email | Effort: Low | Likely impact: Medium | Refills and repeat buys |
| 5 | Checkout upsell (before payment) | Effort: Medium | Likely impact: Medium | Shopify Plus stores |
Best for: Consumables, add-ons
Best for: Stores with long shipping times
Best for: Refills and repeat buys
Checkout upsell (before payment)
Best for: Shopify Plus stores
A post-purchase upsell is an offer a shopper sees right after paying. If they accept, the item is added to the order they just placed.
The key detail is the one click. Upsell.com's listing says its post-purchase funnels are accepted “without entering payment details again.” Aftersell's listing describes “1-click post-purchase upsells.”
This is why post-purchase upsells are low-risk. Product-page and cart upsells can distract a shopper before they buy. After payment, the first order is already safe.
This page sits between payment and the thank-you screen. It shows one product, one price and two buttons: add it, or skip. It is the most visible spot and the one the main apps are built around.
The thank-you page is seen once. The order status page is seen every time the shopper checks on delivery. Both can carry a cross-sell, a referral offer or a survey. Aftersell's listing also mentions earning “up to $0.80 per order” by showing third-party offers there, which is a separate trade-off.
A cross-sell email a few days after delivery works well for refills and accessories. It is also the start of a retention flow, alongside the abandoned cart emails you may already send.
Offers inside the checkout itself, before payment, are a different tool. Both Aftersell's and Upsell.com's listings note that checkout upsells need Shopify Plus. They can lift order value but also add a decision before payment.
The best offer completes what was just bought. It should be an easy yes.
If you already sell multipacks and bundles, the step up to the next pack size is a natural post-purchase offer.

The two best-known Shopify apps for this price very differently. Aftersell charges a flat monthly fee by feature set. Upsell.com charges by your store's order volume or upsell revenue.
Post-purchase app prices, captured November 19, 2026
List prices, USD| Tool | Plan | Price | What you get | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aftersell | Post-Purchase | $34.99/mo | One-click offers, subscription upgrades, thank-you page | apps.shopify.com |
| Aftersell | Complete | $79.99/mo | Adds cart, rewards bar and recommendations | apps.shopify.com |
| Upsell.com (ReConvert) | Free | $0 | Up to 50 orders or $50 upsell revenue | apps.shopify.com |
| Upsell.com (ReConvert) | Paid tiers | $9.99–$39.99/mo | 51 to 500 store orders or upsell revenue | apps.shopify.com |
Aftersell · Post-Purchase
$34.99/moOne-click offers, subscription upgrades, thank-you page
Pricing on apps.shopify.comAftersell · Complete
$79.99/moAdds cart, rewards bar and recommendations
Pricing on apps.shopify.comUpsell.com (ReConvert) · Free
$0Up to 50 orders or $50 upsell revenue
Pricing on apps.shopify.comUpsell.com (ReConvert) · Paid tiers
$9.99–$39.99/mo51 to 500 store orders or upsell revenue
Pricing on apps.shopify.comBoth offered free trials when we checked: 30 days for Aftersell's paid plans and 14 days for Upsell.com's.
For the bigger picture of raising basket size before checkout, see our ranked list of 12 ways to increase average order value.
One-click offers after payment do not, according to the app listings we checked. Upsells inside the checkout itself, before payment, do need Shopify Plus.
No. Post-purchase offers are designed to be accepted with one click, using the payment from the order just placed.
A cheaper item that completes the first purchase: a refill, an accessory, or the next pack size of the same product.
It can't stop the first order, because payment is already done. It can annoy customers if it is irrelevant, so keep it to one or two related offers.
Store examples were captured by the Growth Desk on November 19, 2026. Offers and prices change; what you see on a store today may differ. Spot something out of date? Send us a correction.
All average order value guides, ranked
Twelve ways to get more revenue from each order, ranked by effort and likely payoff, with examples from Bombas, Brooklinen, Glossier and Allbirds.
Average order value · 6 min read

Fixed sets, multipacks, build-your-own packs, value sets and limited drops, with pricing rules and the apps that run them.
Average order value · 5 min read

Why carts get abandoned, the three emails to send, how to capture the address first, and what the tools cost.
Conversion rate · 4 min read
New guides and price changes we spot on vendor pages.