
How to increase average order value: 12 tactics, ranked
Twelve ways to get more revenue from each order, ranked by effort and likely payoff, with examples from Bombas, Brooklinen, Glossier and Allbirds.
Average order value · 6 min read
Set your free shipping threshold a little above your typical order, often 15–30% above the median, then check the margin. The extra items a shopper adds must earn back at least what the shipping costs you. Show the threshold in your top bar and cart so shoppers can aim for it.
By The Growth Desk · Updated · 5 min read

Effort and impact are our estimates
| # | Tactic | Effort | Likely impact | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Threshold just above typical order | Effort: Low | Likely impact: High | Most stores |
| 2 | Free shipping for members | Effort: Medium | Likely impact: Medium | Loyalty programs |
| 3 | Always free shipping | Effort: Low | Likely impact: Medium | High-margin, light items |
| 4 | Flat-rate shipping | Effort: Low | Likely impact: Low | Heavy or bulky goods |
| 5 | Free shipping as a short promo | Effort: Low | Likely impact: Low | Holiday cut-off dates |
Free shipping as a short promo
Best for: Holiday cut-off dates
A free shipping threshold does two jobs. It removes a surprise cost, and it gives shoppers a reason to add one more thing.
The first job matters most. In Baymard Institute's cart abandonment research, 40% of US shoppers who abandoned for a reason other than “just browsing” said extra costs were too high. Another 12% said they couldn't see the total cost up front.
The second job is the one that grows average order value. A shopper at $62 with a $75 line in view has a clear, small goal.
We checked six well-known direct-to-consumer stores on November 19, 2026. Each threshold below is what the store showed on its own site that day.
| Store | Threshold | Where it appears |
|---|---|---|
| Brooklinen | $100 | Top bar; ground shipping, contiguous US |
| Allbirds | $100 | Top bar and cart progress bar |
| Bombas | $75 | Top bar and product page |
| ThirdLove | $75 for members | Rewards panel |
| Manscaped | $49 | Trust strip on the home page |
| Glossier | $40 | Rotating top bar |
| Function of Beauty | $40 | Top bar |

Notice the pattern. The stores with pricier products set higher thresholds. Sheets and shoes sit at $100; shampoo and makeup at $40. The threshold follows the typical basket, not a round number.
You need three numbers from your own store: your median order value, your average shipping cost per order, and your gross margin. Gross margin is the share of the price left after the cost of the product itself.
Here is the math for an imaginary store. The inputs are made up to show the method; swap in your own.
| Input or result | Value | How we got it |
|---|---|---|
| Median order value | $62 | From your order export |
| Average shipping cost | $9 | From your carrier invoices |
| Gross margin | 60% | Price minus product cost |
| Test threshold | $75 | About 21% above the median |
| Gap to close | $13 | $75 − $62 |
| Extra gross profit | $7.80 | $13 × 60% |
| Net effect on that order | −$1.20 | $7.80 − $9 shipping you now pay |
In this example the threshold costs $1.20 on a shopper who adds exactly enough. That can still be a good trade if it saves orders that would have been abandoned at checkout. It is a bad trade if most shoppers were already above $75.
A threshold nobody sees does nothing. Put it where the decision happens.

Some stores tie free shipping to an account. ThirdLove's rewards panel said “Join for free to earn rewards & free shipping on $75+.” Prose offered “15% off + free shipping for members.”
This trades a little friction for an email address you can use later, for example in abandoned cart emails. It suits stores with frequent repeat orders.
If your products are light and your margins are high, free shipping on everything may be simpler. There is nothing to explain, and it removes the cost objection completely.
Heavy or bulky goods are the opposite. A low flat rate, shown on the product page, is often more honest than a threshold few shoppers can reach.
Threshold tools, prices captured November 19, 2026
List prices, USD| Tool | Plan | Price | What you get | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify shipping settings | Built in | $0 | Free rate with a minimum order price | help.shopify.com |
| Hextom Free Shipping Bar | Basic | $0 | Customizable bar, page and device targeting | apps.shopify.com |
| Hextom Free Shipping Bar | Premium | $9.99/mo | Unlimited bars, geo targeting, scheduling | apps.shopify.com |
Shopify shipping settings · Built in
$0Free rate with a minimum order price
Pricing on help.shopify.comHextom Free Shipping Bar · Basic
$0Customizable bar, page and device targeting
Pricing on apps.shopify.comHextom Free Shipping Bar · Premium
$9.99/moUnlimited bars, geo targeting, scheduling
Pricing on apps.shopify.comIt is the order total above which a store ships for free. Brooklinen's was $100 when we checked; Glossier's was $40.
A common starting point is 15–30% above your median order value. Then check that the extra margin from added items roughly covers your shipping cost.
It targets the top fixable cause. Baymard Institute found 40% of US shoppers who abandoned for a reason other than browsing blamed extra costs such as shipping.
Lowering it for a short, announced window can work around holidays. Changing it often confuses returning shoppers.
Store examples were captured by the Growth Desk on November 19, 2026. Offers and prices change; what you see on a store today may differ. Spot something out of date? Send us a correction.
All average order value guides, ranked
Twelve ways to get more revenue from each order, ranked by effort and likely payoff, with examples from Bombas, Brooklinen, Glossier and Allbirds.
Average order value · 6 min read

Fixed sets, multipacks, build-your-own packs, value sets and limited drops, with pricing rules and the apps that run them.
Average order value · 5 min read

Why carts get abandoned, the three emails to send, how to capture the address first, and what the tools cost.
Conversion rate · 4 min read
New guides and price changes we spot on vendor pages.